Living in the Grey to Uncover the Green

Andy Brandel, PE
,
Executive Vice President
October 11, 2021

If generations could be defined by one word, an apt phrase for our current period may be “immediacy”.  This sense of immediacy courses through our society, influencing not only how we experience our entertainment, but how we gather and disseminate information and develop our policies. Though I can appreciate the occasions when speedy responses and decisiveness are required, a negative outcome of constricting the deliberation of a thing is that we grossly oversimplify the options available to us. We take complex issues and distill them down to either/or scenarios. The tendency toward immediacy demands a confrontation of the sides and requires a person to be either for or against a topic. We are no longer allowed to hold the tension of the opposites in our mind and consider that both/and may be the more appropriate option. I think this is a vital lens from which to view our discussions surrounding the use and production of our energy portfolio.

Emission reductions vs. unfunded mandates, climate change believers vs. hoax enthusiasts, renewable energy vs. fossil fuels, cheap energy vs. sustainable energy, etc. The way these discussions are being presented requires one to pick a side. Furthermore, it nearly mandates that the opposing side be vilified. Meanwhile, there is absolutely no appreciation for the nuance this complex situation presents. There is a real story to be told regarding the depletion of our polar ice caps, the rising atmospheric temperatures, and the increasing sea levels. These climate stories demand that we evaluate how we generate and use energy. Conversely, there is a real human story attached to the abandonment of coal mines and power plants, land lost to wind and solar fields, and the burdensome cost of updating an aged grid system to accept new energy sources. These personal stories demand that we carefully evaluate all options before taking extreme measures. None of this is an either/or. If we are to provide meaningful, lasting solutions to any of these issues, the approach must include both/and. Both stories are real and both stories need to be held in consideration. I believe they can, if (and I know how unpopular a sentiment this will be) we resist the demand for immediacy— the impulse to draw your line in the sand and pick a side right now.

There may be a strong reaction to that statement and an assumption that what I am recommending is that we don’t act. Please hear me and try to understand. I find the evidence surrounding the immensely harmful impacts of humankind’s free use of fossil fuels to be undeniable. And though I have only ever scratched the surface of the research on the topic, I find it feasible that if left unchecked, our abuse of the environment could become irreversible. It is imperative that we lose no time in shifting course. However, I also know that those companies that have engineered our energy systems are part of the solution and have the expertise to develop the tools to get us moving in the right direction. Gas companies, industrial plants, manufacturers—they are the seeming pariah of the clean energy movement, but need not be. They can be, and in most cases already are, allies in the everchanging frontier for a cleaner world.

We are neck-deep in both/and, and that’s exactly where we need to be. We need both the ingenuity and passion of the “environmentalist” and the practicality and expertise of the “traditionalist” to forge a new equitable and sustainable path for everyone. My work as an engineer at ISG allows me the opportunity to interact with this dichotomy daily. It has helped me to settle into the grey space of nuance—the space we need to get comfortable in to find a beautifully green new world.

No items found.
Andy Brandel, PE
Executive Vice President
More from
Andy Brandel, PE

Related Articles

Building a Smarter Water Quality Data System Through Custom Technology

Water quality data offers critical insights into the health and safety of water resources, providing data to track ecosystem health and support restoration efforts.

Industry Insights

The Benefits of Using Recycled Water for Industrial Use

Industrial food processing facilities depend on complex operations that often require significant quantities of water.

Industry Insights

ISG and Mankato Area Public Schools Expand Career Exploration Program Connecting High School Students to Architecture, Engineering, and Construction Administration

ISG partnered with Mankato Area Public Schools (MAPS) to introduce an Architecture, Engineering, and Construction (AEC) track within the existing MAPS Career Exploration Program.

Industry Insights

Drainage Water Recycling: Multi-Purpose Benefits for Producers, Crops, and the Areas They Impact

Throughout the Midwest, agricultural best management practices are ripe with opportunity and innovation, with new, targeted strategies to meet the evolving demands of modern farming while managing unpredictable weather.

Industry Insights

It's More Than A Vote

ISG believes the path to a successful yes vote doesn’t begin with a ballot. It begins with a story, a strategy, and the community.

Industry Insights

Ensuring Electrical Safety Through New Mandates: The Role of NFPA 70B Compliant Maintenance Programs

Maintaining, testing, and training are important elements of a successful electrical safety program for any facility. As of 2023, NFPA 70B, the Standard for Electrical Equipment Maintenance, has transitioned from a recommendation to an enforceable standard.

Industry Insights